Google search results?

So, our church admin at long last has a functional web page up-- but it's about 4 pages deep on Google when one searches the obvious term (Community Lutheran Church VT). How do we get it to move up in the results, short of advertising?

The new page is: http://clcvt.org

The first result to come up is a nonfunctional shell that an unscrupulous web designer did "free"-- and then demanded really enormous amounts of money for making it functional, and refused to give up the domain or take the page down when we opted not to pay. Very frustrating.